Jack Park wrote:
> Let's get on with building tools.
Actually, to consider Ess's outstandingly articulated
observations for a moment, should we really get on
with building tools?
I was particulary struck by the 3rd world resistance
to technology and tools. Earlier today I observed that
"The quest for utopia doth make Don Quixote's of us all."
I think there is some truth to that. And, to be frank,
I'm not sure I really like the collective western vision
Here in the west, we tend to assume that more utopian
conditions will involve more technology. I think that
may well be true, up to a point. But identifying that
"point" is tricky business.
I would say that my main reservation about the use of
technology in the west is that, while it is almost
always sold as a "labor enhancing device", invariably
it is anything but. While the device in question almost
always does save labor, our social structure is such
that we are compelled to use the time saved to do more.
As a result, overall productivity grows, but the amount
of actual labor scarecely diminishes. Meanwhile, the
existence of a competitive economy (lots of folks making
socks), rather than a cooperative one (you make socks,
I'll make shoes) means that we never really have time to
relax. If we want our company/organization to survive,
we put in 60, 70, 80 hour weeks. Where is the labor
Given what we can do now, vs. what we could do 100 years
ago, we could be working 5 or 6 hours a week, couldn't
we. We'd have less (and I'm so much of a materialist
that I'd be dissatisfied with less, I admit it) -- but
if we had the ability to be satisfied with less, we'd
have much less impact on the environment, and a lot less
stress in our lives.
It occurs to me, in fact, that the "utopia factor" can
be measured as the inverse of the amount of (involuntary)
stress in our lives. If we're stressed -- due to hunger,
cold, or overwork) then we're not living in utopia. But
if we're doing enough to feel productive and appreciated,
and have no worries, then we *are* in utopia, aren't we?
Yours with a slightly different world view...
(And to think I used to hack until dawn out of college.
gad. Times have changed. Must be getting old. :_)
Post message: unrev-II@onelist.com
List owner: unrev-IIemail@example.com
Shortcut URL to this page:
Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : Thu Jun 28 2001 - 15:27:19 PDT